 Buena Vista UniversityDIIIStorm Lake, IA | American Rivers Conference (ARC) | Kelsey Resnick4th season since 2023 | 23 | |
 Cairn University-LanghorneDIIILanghorne, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Luke Gibson13th season since 2014 | 32 | |
 California Institute of TechnologyDIIIPasadena, CA | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) | Duncan Gillis6th season since 2021 | 29 | |
 California Lutheran UniversityDIIIThousand Oaks, CA | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) | Miguel Ruiz9th season since 2018 | 40 | |
 Calvin UniversityDIIIGrand Rapids, MI | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association (MIAA) | Ryan Souders | 32 | |
 Capital UniversityDIIIColumbus, OH | Ohio Athletic Conference (OAC) | Corey Kirk3rd season since 2024 | 32 | |
 Carleton CollegeDIIINorthfield, MN | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (MIAC) | Bob Carlson | 31 | |
 Carlow UniversityDIIIPittsburgh, PA | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC) | Allen Duda | 21 | |
 Carnegie Mellon UniversityDIIIPittsburgh, PA | University Athletic Association (UAA) | Brandon Bowman | 33 | |
 Carroll UniversityDIIIWaukesha, WI | College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW) | Andy Kohel | 40 | |
 Carthage CollegeDIIIKenosha, WI | College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW) | Mike Madigan | 48 | |
 Case Western Reserve UniversityDIIICleveland, OH | University Athletic Association (UAA) | Carter Poe7th season since 2020 | 33 | |
 Castleton UniversityDIIICastleton, VT | Little East Conference (LEC) | John O'Connor15th season since 2012 | 27 | |
 Centenary College of LouisianaDIIIShreveport, LA | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference (SCAC) | Joseph O'Sullivan | 33 | |
 Centenary UniversityDIIIHackettstown, NJ | Atlantic East Conference (AEC) | Alex Idrovo1st season since 2026 | 32 | |
 Central CollegeDIIIPella, IA | American Rivers Conference (ARC) | Garry Laidlaw | 42 | |
 Centre CollegeDIIIDanville, KY | Southern Athletic Association (SAA) | Jeb Burch '94 | 30 | |
 Chapman UniversityDIIIOrange, CA | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) | Eddie Carrillo '90 | 34 | |
 Chatham UniversityDIIIPittsburgh, PA | Presidents Athletic Conference (PAC) | Nick Taljan | 26 | |
 Christopher Newport UniversityDIIINewport News, VA | Coast-to-Coast Athletic Conference (CAC) | Justin Chezem | 35 | |
 Claremont McKenna-Harvey Mudd-ScrippsDIIIClaremont, CA | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) | Edward Cartee5th season since 2022 | 37 | |
 Clark UniversityDIIIWorcester, MA | NEWMAC | Samuel Matteson3rd season since 2024 | 28 | |
 Clarkson UniversityDIIIPotsdam, NY | Liberty League (LL) | Carter Lincoln | 35 | |
 Coe CollegeDIIICedar Rapids, IA | American Rivers Conference (ARC) | Kyle Bakas | 34 | |
 Colby CollegeDIIIWaterville, ME | New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC) | Sean Elvert | 37 | |
 Colby-Sawyer CollegeDIIINew London, NH | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Zachary Grady | 30 | |
 College of Our Lady of the ElmsDIIIChicopee, MA | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Mike Wysocki | 25 | |
 Colorado CollegeDIIIColorado Springs, CO · Tigers | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference (SCAC) | Scott Palguta11th season since 2016 | 28 | |
 Concordia College at MoorheadDIIIMoorhead, MN | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (MIAC) | Nick Zuchowski | 27 | |
 Concordia University TexasDIIIAustin, TX | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference (SCAC) | Jordan Parron | 38 | |
 Concordia University-ChicagoDIIIRiver Forest, IL | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | Graham Brennan1st season since 2026 | 29 | |
 Concordia University-WisconsinDIIIMequon, WI | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | John Saleska | 49 | |
 Connecticut CollegeDIIINew London, CT | New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC) | Reuben Burk9th season since 2018 | 37 | |
 Cornell CollegeDIIIMount Vernon, IA | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Nate Grosse | 23 | |
 Covenant CollegeDIIILookout Mountain, GA | Collegiate Conference of the South (CCS) | Scott Bosgraf10th season since 2017 | 32 | |
 Crown CollegeDIIISaint Bonifacius, MN | Upper Midwest Conference (MWC) | Alex Hosler | 17 | |
| CUNY Bernard M Baruch College DIIINew York, NY | City University of New York Athletic Conference (CUNY) | Andrew Jenkins | 29 | |
 CUNY Brooklyn CollegeDIIIBrooklyn, NY | City University of New York Athletic Conference (CUNY) | Ronald Stanislaus1st season since 2026 | 30 | |
 CUNY City CollegeDIIINew York, NY | City University of New York Athletic Conference (CUNY) | Roger Gonzalez | 31 | |
| CUNY Hunter College DIIINew York, NY | City University of New York Athletic Conference (CUNY) | Evan Reifsnyder2nd season since 2025 | 36 | |
