 Keystone CollegeDIIILa Plume, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Clint Caso | 26 | |
 King's CollegeDIIIWilkes-Barre, PA | Middle Atlantic Freedom Conference (MAC Freedom) | BRANDON RAYNOR | 34 | |
 Knox CollegeDIIIGalesburg, IL | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Pablo Arriaga | 33 | |
 La Roche UniversityDIIIPittsburgh, PA | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC) | Not listed | 30 | |
 LaGrange CollegeDIIILagrange, GA | Collegiate Conference of the South (CCS) | Ryan Dickson | 27 | |
 Lake Forest CollegeDIIILake Forest, IL | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Dan Andrews | 38 | |
 Lakeland UniversityDIIIPlymouth, WI | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | Kyle Quintell3rd season since 2024 | 50 | |
 Lancaster Bible CollegeDIIILancaster, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Tom Ardt16th season since 2011 | 30 | |
 Lasell UniversityDIIINewton, MA | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Not listed | 25 | |
 Lawrence UniversityDIIIAppleton, WI | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Ben Gyuricza | 35 | |
 Lebanon Valley CollegeDIIIAnnville, PA | Middle Atlantic Freedom Conference (MAC Freedom) | Charlie Grimes | 36 | |
 Lesley UniversityDIIICambridge, MA | North Atlantic Conference (NAC) | Not listed | 28 | |
 LeTourneau UniversityDIIILongview, TX | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference (SCAC) | TJ Milby2nd season since 2025 | 32 | |
 Lewis & Clark CollegeDIIIPortland, OR | Northwest Conference (NWC) | Fraser Morrison5th season since 2022 | 30 | |
 Linfield UniversityDIIIMcMinnville, OR | Northwest Conference (NWC) | Andrew Duvall7th season since 2020 | 39 | |
 Loras CollegeDIIIDubuque, IA | American Rivers Conference (ARC) | Nick Rizzo | 53 | |
 Luther CollegeDIIIDecorah, IA | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Chris Garcia-Prats | 39 | |
 Lycoming CollegeDIIIWilliamsport, PA | Landmark Conference (LC) | John Schwien | 28 | |
 Lyon CollegeDIIIBatesville, AR | St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SLIAC) | Emanuel Santos | 45 | |
 Macalester CollegeDIIISaint Paul, MN | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (MIAC) | Gregg Olson15th season since 2012 | 28 | |
 Maine Maritime AcademyDIIICastine, ME | North Atlantic Conference (NAC) | Billy Shannon | 26 | |
 Manchester UniversityDIIINorth Manchester, IN | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference (HCAC) | Olaoluwade Ladapo2nd season since 2025 | 27 | |
 Manhattanville UniversityDIIIPurchase, NY | Skyline Conference (SC) | Tom Buckner | 41 | |
 Maranatha Baptist UniversityDIIIWatertown, WI | Independent | Jeff Pill | 20 | |
 Marian UniversityDIIIFond Du Lac, WI | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | Keegan Miller4th season since 2023 | 28 | |
 Marietta CollegeDIIIMarietta, OH | Ohio Athletic Conference (OAC) | Joe Bergin14th season since 2013 | 35 | |
 Martin Luther CollegeDIIINew Ulm, MN | Upper Midwest Conference (MWC) | Nicolas Schmoller5th season since 2022 | 21 | |
 Mary Baldwin UniversityDIIIStaunton, VA | USA South Athletic Conference (USAC) | Zack Clark | 33 | |
 Marymount UniversityDIIIArlington, VA | Atlantic East Conference (AEC) | Nate Kalin8th season since 2019 | 39 | |
 Maryville CollegeDIIIMaryville, TN | Southern Athletic Association (SAA) | Pepe Fernandez | 37 | |
 Marywood UniversityDIIIScranton, PA | Middle Atlantic Conference (MAC) | Brian Osborne2nd season since 2025 | 34 | |
 Massachusetts College of Liberal ArtsDIIINorth Adams, MA | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC) | Adam Hildabrand | 26 | |
 Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyDIIICambridge, MA | NEWMAC | Andrew Storton1st season since 2026 | 34 | |
 Massachusetts Maritime AcademyDIIIBuzzards Bay, MA | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC) | Greg Perry | 33 | |
 McDaniel CollegeDIIIWestminster, MD | Centennial Conference (CC) | Steve Corrieri | 26 | |
 McMurry UniversityDIIIAbilene, TX | American Southwest Conference (ASC) | Lorenzo Segura | 27 | |
 Messiah UniversityDIIIMechanicsburg, PA | Middle Atlantic Conference (MAC) | Brad McCarty | 26 | |
 Methodist UniversityDIIIFayetteville, NC | USA South Athletic Conference (USAC) | Justin Terranova | 37 | |
 Middlebury CollegeDIIIMiddlebury, VT | New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC) | Alex Elias | 35 | |
 Millikin UniversityDIIIDecatur, IL | College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW) | Charlie Ward3rd season since 2024 | 36 | |
