 Millsaps CollegeDIIIJackson, MS | Southern Athletic Association (SAA) | Gentry Johnson4th season since 2023 | 45 | |
 Milwaukee School of EngineeringDIIIMilwaukee, WI | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | Rob Harrington | 34 | |
 Misericordia UniversityDIIIDallas, PA | Middle Atlantic Freedom Conference (MAC Freedom) | Alistair Moore3rd season since 2024 | 34 | |
 Mississippi University for WomenDIIIColumbus, MS | St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SLIAC) | Stewart Mena | 23 | |
 Mitchell CollegeDIIINew London, CT | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Cam Pilger | 28 | |
 Monmouth CollegeDIIIMonmouth, IL | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Ian Hatleli7th season since 2020 | 26 | |
 Montclair State UniversityDIIIMontclair, NJ | New Jersey Athletic Conference (NJAC) | Todd Tumelty16th season since 2011 | 33 | |
 Moravian UniversityDIIIBethlehem, PA | Landmark Conference (LC) | Bob Wilkinson | 40 | |
 Mount Aloysius CollegeDIIICresson, PA | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC) | Matt Davis | 35 | |
 Mount Saint Mary CollegeDIIINewburgh, NY | Skyline Conference (SC) | Kevin Longacre16th season since 2011 | 28 | |
 Mount St. Joseph UniversityDIIICincinnati, OH | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference (HCAC) | Anthony Clark2nd season since 2025 | 30 | |
 Muhlenberg CollegeDIIIAllentown, PA | Centennial Conference (CC) | Sean Topping | 32 | |
 Muskingum UniversityDIIINew Concord, OH | Ohio Athletic Conference (OAC) | Josh Lubich | 28 | |
 Nazareth UniversityDIIIRochester, NY | Empire 8 Conference (E8) | Not listed | 37 | |
 Nebraska Wesleyan UniversityDIIILincoln, NE | American Rivers Conference (ARC) | Brandon Bonilla9th season since 2018 | 33 | |
 Neumann UniversityDIIIAston, PA | Middle Atlantic Conference (MAC) | Erik Temple4th season since 2023 | 35 | |
 New England CollegeDIIIHenniker, NH | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Pat Laughlin | 29 | |
 New Jersey City UniversityDIIIJersey City, NJ | New Jersey Athletic Conference (NJAC) | Jairo Munoz3rd season since 2024 | 32 | |
 New York UniversityDIIINew York, NY | University Athletic Association (UAA) | Kim Wyant | 30 | |
 Nichols CollegeDIIIDudley, MA | Conference of New England (CNE) | Marco DeVito | 34 | |
 North Carolina Wesleyan UniversityDIIIRocky Mount, NC | USA South Athletic Conference (USAC) | Mark Bowman5th season since 2022 | 40 | |
 North Central CollegeDIIINaperville, IL | College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW) | Enzo Fuschino | 35 | |
 North Central UniversityDIIIMinneapolis, MN | Upper Midwest Conference (MWC) | Keith Bleyer3rd season since 2024 | 27 | |
 North Park UniversityDIIIChicago, IL | College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW) | Kris Grahn8th season since 2019 | 47 | |
 Norwich UniversityDIIINorthfield, VT | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Robert Emmett3rd season since 2024 | 30 | |
 Notre Dame of Maryland UniversityDIIIBaltimore, MD | United East Conference (UEC) | Frank Olszewski | 27 | |
 Oberlin CollegeDIIIOberlin, OH | North Coast Athletic Conference (NCAC) | Blake New27th season since 2000 | 33 | |
 Occidental CollegeDIIILos Angeles, CA | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) | Rod Lafaurie | 36 | |
 Oglethorpe UniversityDIIIAtlanta, GA | Southern Athletic Association (SAA) | Jon Akin | 33 | |
 Ohio Northern UniversityDIIIAda, OH | Ohio Athletic Conference (OAC) | Chris Matejka | 43 | |
 Ohio Wesleyan UniversityDIIIDelaware, OH | North Coast Athletic Conference (NCAC) | Matt Weiss2nd season since 2025 | 34 | |
 Otterbein UniversityDIIIWesterville, OH | Ohio Athletic Conference (OAC) | Jason Griffiths | 28 | |
 Pacific Lutheran UniversityDIIITacoma, WA | Northwest Conference (NWC) | John Yorke24th season since 2003 | 35 | |
 Pacific UniversityDIIIForest Grove, OR | Northwest Conference (NWC) | Brandon Porter | 32 | |
 Pennsylvania College of TechnologyDIIIWilliamsport, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Tyler Mensch | 38 | |
 Pennsylvania State University-Penn State AbingtonDIIIAbington, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Pat Morris4th season since 2023 | 34 | |
 Pennsylvania State University-Penn State AltoonaDIIIAltoona, PA | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC) | Evan Cardoza | 25 | |
 Pennsylvania State University-Penn State BerksDIIIReading, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Steve Small2nd season since 2025 | 29 | |
| Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Brandywine DIIIMedia, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Bill Bono | 20 | |
 Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Erie-Behrend CollegeDIIIErie, PA | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference (AMCC) | Chris Ralph | 24 | |
