 Pennsylvania State University-Penn State HarrisburgDIIIMiddletown, PA | United East Conference (UEC) | Colby Gay1st season since 2026 | 29 | |
 Pfeiffer UniversityDIIIMisenheimer, NC | USA South Athletic Conference (USAC) | Tony Faticoni11th season since 2016 | 41 | |
 Piedmont UniversityDIIIDemorest, GA | Collegiate Conference of the South (CCS) | Jimmy Stephens22nd season since 2005 | 28 | |
 Plymouth State UniversityDIIIPlymouth, NH | Little East Conference (LEC) | Rob Wright25th season since 2002 | 26 | |
 Pomona CollegeDIIIClaremont, CA | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) | Clint Moore2nd season since 2025 | 34 | |
 Pratt Institute-MainDIIIBrooklyn, NY | Atlantic East Conference (AEC) | Stavros Zomopoulos6th season since 2021 | 19 | |
 Principia CollegeDIIIElsah, IL | St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SLIAC) | Christian Tresoldi | 27 | |
 Ramapo College of New JerseyDIIIMahwah, NJ | New Jersey Athletic Conference (NJAC) | DJ Pinton | 32 | |
 Randolph CollegeDIIILynchburg, VA | Old Dominion Athletic Conference (ODAC) | Sheldon Blue3rd season since 2024 | 29 | |
 Randolph-Macon CollegeDIIIAshland, VA | Old Dominion Athletic Conference (ODAC) | Josh Laux | 39 | |
 Regent UniversityDIIIVirginia Beach, VA | Coast-to-Coast Athletic Conference (CAC) | Not listed | 24 | |
 Regis CollegeDIIIWeston, MA | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Alex Elia | 28 | |
 Rensselaer Polytechnic InstituteDIIITroy, NY | Liberty League (LL) | Adam Clinton25th season since 2002 | 34 | |
 Rhode Island CollegeDIIIProvidence, RI | Little East Conference (LEC) | Kyle Froberg5th season since 2022 | 26 | |
 Rhodes CollegeDIIIMemphis, TN | Southern Athletic Association (SAA) | Matt Lamb | 36 | |
 Ripon CollegeDIIIRipon, WI | Midwest Conference (MWC) | Not listed | 38 | |
 Rivier UniversityDIIINashua, NH | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Jon Cross3rd season since 2024 | 31 | |
 Roanoke CollegeDIIISalem, VA | Old Dominion Athletic Conference (ODAC) | Ryan Pflugrad '02 | 32 | |
 Rochester Institute of TechnologyDIIIRochester, NY | Liberty League (LL) | Bill Garno | 32 | |
 Rockford UniversityDIIIRockford, IL | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | Ethan Higgins2nd season since 2025 | 29 | |
 Roger Williams UniversityDIIIBristol, RI | Conference of New England (CNE) | James Greenslit | 37 | |
 Rose-Hulman Institute of TechnologyDIIITerre Haute, IN | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference (HCAC) | Sean Helliwell | 35 | |
 Rowan UniversityDIIIGlassboro, NJ | New Jersey Athletic Conference (NJAC) | Scott Baker13th season since 2014 | 35 | |
 Russell Sage CollegeDIIITroy, NY | Empire 8 Conference (E8) | Amir Pasic | 33 | |
 Rutgers University-CamdenDIIICamden, NJ | New Jersey Athletic Conference (NJAC) | Tim Oswald | 38 | |
 Rutgers University-NewarkDIIINewark, NJ | New Jersey Athletic Conference (NJAC) | Kevin East | 37 | |
 Saint Elizabeth UniversityDIIIMorristown, NJ | Atlantic East Conference (AEC) | Alfonso Nunez Perez | 24 | |
 Saint Francis UniversityDIIILoretto, PA | Presidents Athletic Conference (PAC) | Shelby Edwards1st season since 2026 | 16 | |
| Saint John's University (MN) DIIICollegeville, MN | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (MIAC) | Tudor Flintham2nd season since 2025 | 36 | |
 Saint Joseph's College of MaineDIIIStandish, ME | Great Northeast Athletic Conference (GNAC) | Will Pike '118th season since 2019 | 23 | |
 Saint Mary's University of MinnesotaDIIIWinona, MN | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (MIAC) | Leo Barbosa | 32 | |
 Saint Norbert CollegeDIIIDe Pere, WI | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NACC) | Derek Rhodes14th season since 2013 | 32 | |
 Saint Vincent CollegeDIIILatrobe, PA | Presidents Athletic Conference (PAC) | Tyler Gallagher2nd season since 2025 | 29 | |
 Salem State UniversityDIIISalem, MA | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC) | Matt Correia | 29 | |
 Salisbury UniversityDIIISalisbury, MD | Coast-to-Coast Athletic Conference (CAC) | Zack MacDougall5th season since 2022 | 35 | |
 Salve Regina UniversityDIIINewport, RI | NEWMAC | Bill Lawler3rd season since 2024 | 32 | |
 Sarah Lawrence CollegeDIIIBronxville, NY | Skyline Conference (SC) | Gianluca Orsini | 19 | |
 Schreiner UniversityDIIIKerrville, TX | American Southwest Conference (ASC) | Not listed | 37 | |
 Shenandoah UniversityDIIIWinchester, VA | Old Dominion Athletic Conference (ODAC) | Brandon Kates | 35 | |
 Simpson CollegeDIIIIndianola, IA | American Rivers Conference (ARC) | Rick Isaacson | 41 | |
